POST INSURANCE BEST INSURANCE COMPANY

As seen in the "Best of Port St. Lucie 2025" Sponsored Feature in the summer issue of Port St. Lucie Magazine
June, 2025

BEST INSURANCE COMPANY | Best of PSL 2025

Post Insurance: The Best in Port St. Lucie

Kathy Post got her start working in the family insurance agency in 1979 as a kid  — typing labels and answering phones. “I was working before I knew long division,” she jokes.

That early work ethic was important. Kathy shares, “But more important, was learning from my parents that building relationships and helping people matters most.”

A licensed agent for 40 years and owner and CEO for 28 years, Kathy has grown Post Insurance into a trusted, full-service agency with a well-deserved reputation for integrity, personalized service and deep community ties. Winning this year’s “Best of Port St. Lucie” recognition attests to the loyalty clients feel towards Post Insurance. 

“We’re grateful for this recognition. We’re proud to serve our clients and community,” Kathy says.

PERSONAL AND MULTI-GENERATIONAL

Post Insurance is a true family business. Kathy’s sister, Becky, has managed operations for over 20 years, and Kathy’s daughter, Kassia, now represents the third generation serving the community.

Their legacy is reflected in their loyal client base —  many of whom are the children and grandchildren of their father’s original customers. Kathy shares, “Our clients are more than policies — they’re friends, family, and neighbors.”

LOCAL TRUSTED ADVISORS

In Florida’s complex insurance environ-ment, Post Insurance stands out as a trusted advisor and advocate guided by integrity and a commitment to client education.

“We help clients balance the budget needs of today against the unknown risks of tomorrow,” Kathy adds.

The staff happily review competitor quotes to explain cost and coverage differences in plain language to debunk myths.

Whether adjusting deductibles, reviewing needs, or explaining policy language, the team spends time helping clients make informed decisions.

“The worst time to find out something isn’t covered by insurance is after something bad happens,” says Kathy. “We want clients to know what is covered — and what is excluded — before there’s a claim.”

GIVING BACK TO THE COMMUNITY

Community involvement is woven into the fabric of Post Insurance. Post Insurance actively supports local nonprofits, civic groups, and faith-based organizations. Employees receive paid volunteer time and nonprofits share their missions during staff meetings — often highlighted in client newsletters.  

“Giving back is part of our culture. We seek ways staff and clients can give back, building stronger community ties,” Kathy says.

WHAT SETS POST INSURANCE APART

Kathy credits her staff’s dedication, professionalism —and heart —for making their longevity and success.

“Many of my staff have been with us 15+ years. Their commitment to excellence, their devotion to their clients, and their embodiment of our core values are what sets Post Insurance apart,” she adds.

The agency motto is: Your key to peace of mind. Kathy shares, “For us, that’s more than a slogan, it’s our way of life.”

Post Insurance is located in St. Lucie West at 146 NW Central Park Plaza, #102 Port St. Lucie, FL 34986. For more information, call 772.878.8184 or visit InsureWithPost.com.